The act of sifting through inherited belongings often serves as a doorway to the past, leading individuals to pieces of history that spark profound memories and emotions. Recently, I aided my mother in navigating through boxes left behind by my late grandparents, a task that evoked both nostalgia and contemplation. One particular box, whimsically labeled “toothpick holders and other treasures”, lacked the promised toothpick holders but overflowed with other relics that told stories of lives once lived. Among these artifacts was a single puzzle piece, reminiscent of my grandmother’s fondness for mischievously concealing the last piece of any jigsaw puzzle, only to claim it at the end. While the box stirred a multitude of sentiments, it also prompted an essential question that has emerged in my personal and professional endeavors: why do we keep what we keep?
As a licensed clinical psychologist specializing in hoarding disorder—particularly among older adults—this question has critical implications for my field. Hoarding disorder is classified as a psychiatric condition marked by an overwhelming compulsion to save items, resulting in substantial clutter that infringes on one’s daily life. For individuals severely affected by this condition, the clutter can lead to dire consequences, including safety hazards and compromised well-being. Yet, beyond the boundaries of clinical severity, many adults, irrespective of diagnosis, grapple with clutter, often holding onto items laden with sentimental value or perceived utility.
As we age, our relationship with possessions and decision-making evolves, often influenced by declines in executive function. This change can exacerbate the propensity to cling to items, fogging decision-making processes related to their disposal. Traditional theories around hoarding suggest that the difficulty in parting with possessions stems from anxiety during decision-making. However, my research highlights an emerging understanding: particularly among older adults, the decluttering process can evoke positive emotions, challenging the notion that distress is the primary barrier to effective decision-making.
In various studies I have conducted, I’ve observed that many older adults, when faced with discarding decisions, exhibit surprisingly low levels of stress. Instead of feeling anxiety, they often report emotional uplift while sorting through their belongings. This shift in perspective suggests that the impulse to save items may not primarily stem from fear of loss, but from a profound sense of value and altruism. Participants frequently express sentiments such as, “This belongs in a good home,” or “My grandmother gave this to me,” highlighting an intrinsic motivation that aligns with personal values.
A recent study conducted by my team explored how understanding one’s values directly impacts the decluttering process. By facilitating conversations about what matters most to individuals—be it family, health, or environmental responsibility—we noticed a marked improvement in their ability to declutter. This values-based approach fosters a sense of purpose and direction, urging individuals to engage not merely with the act of letting go, but with the principles that guide their decisions.
From my observations and research, there are practical steps people—especially older adults—can take to help them navigate the often daunting process of decluttering. First and foremost is to articulate one’s values. Understanding what truly matters allows individuals to assess each item not just as a mere object but in relation to its meaning within their lives.
For instance, someone who values creativity might prioritize keeping art supplies or cookbooks featuring innovative recipes. Conversely, if a person treasures family memories, an heirloom might hold more significance than an item acquired casually—focusing on sentimental versus practical values can ease decision-making immensely.
It’s also essential to create goal-oriented spaces. Whether clearing a desk for improved productivity or making room in the kitchen for memorable moments with grandchildren, aligning decluttering efforts with meaningful outcomes transforms the task from a burden into a rewarding journey of reconnection.
Moreover, acknowledging value conflicts is vital. Personal values can at times clash when decluttering—recognizing these instances can further clarify one’s intentions about what to keep or discard. A compassionate, curious approach from caregivers can assist loved ones in confronting their clutter, enabling them to see their possessions through a lens free from judgment.
In summation, the relationship we cultivate with our belongings reflects not just our history but also our values and aspirations. Approaching the clutter with an understanding of its emotional context allows for a revival of purpose—transforming the chaotic remnants of the past into meaningful reflections of our present selves. Through research and clinical experience, I advocate for a values-based decluttering strategy, not just for those grappling with hoarding disorder, but for anyone eager to redefine their living space while honoring what truly matters. As we navigate the complexities of our possessions, we can reclaim the narrative of our lives, one valued object at a time.
Leave a Reply